Research Blog #9: Argument & Counterargument

 

Throughout my paper, I explain Sigmund Freud’s interpretation of the unconscious mind and how it relates to déjà vu and dreams. I believe that Freud’s theories are the most accurate interpretations. Freud believes that the unconscious mind holds repressed thoughts, traumatic memories, and overall unpleasant feelings such as anxiety, pain, and conflict. In relation to dreams, he believes that our dreams are able to access the unconscious and can explain a lot about us.

As a counterargument, I wanted to dive into Carl Jung’s theories of the unconscious and dreams. Freud and Jung were good friends/colleagues so a lot of what Freud believed is also something that Jung believed, but there were still some disagreements between the two. Jung believes that the personal unconscious includes recalled and suppressed memories, and the collective unconscious holds our experiences or knowledge that we have had since birth. While I don’t exactly agree with his view on the unconscious, I do agree with his interpretation of dreams. Jung believed that dreams can also tell a lot about a person, but unlike Freud, he did not believe that what occurs in dreams is sexual in nature. This is an idea that is prominent throughout the majority of Freud’s work and is something that I don’t agree with so I don’t incorporate it into my paper. Jung focused more on symbolic imagery in dreams and the interpretation of a dream can vary between people. At the beginning of the semester, I remember we had to read a piece by Jung and it also explained how symbolic imagery was a big concept for his theories, and it really stuck with me. Jung also feels that dreams could possibly anticipate future events which I believe can be true (Blundell).

As much as I believe that déjà vu mainly deals with the unconscious and other parts of our lives (like if a person has anxiety or not), Jung’s theory of synchronicity and interpretation of dreams is honestly a great theory to explain why déjà vu occurs. Jung explained an encounter he had with a woman patient of his who was about to tell the doctor about a previous dream she had. In the dream “she was given a golden scarab in form of a piece of jewelry” (Forrer). As she was telling the dream, Jung turns around to a noise at the window which ended up being a beetle “whose gold-green colour closely resembled that of a golden scarab” (Forrer). He then handed the beetle to the patient saying it was her scarab. Jung didn’t notice at first, but this incident wasn’t his dream that was recalled in the course of its manifestation, but it was the patient’s dream. If this did happen to him then he would’ve recognized it to be déjà vu. “And if the scarab episode was a déjà vu as I maintain, then that ‘causal bridge between the elements making up a meaningful coincidence or a synchronicity’ is clearly a dream. In other words a synchronistic episode is nothing more mysterious than the manifestation of a dream” (Forrer). In this incident, Jung has helped complete a déjà vu experience for the patient.


Citations

Blundell, Andrea. “Freud vs Jung - Similarities and Differences.” Harley Therapy™ Blog, 20 Feb. 2014, www.harleytherapy.co.uk/counselling/freud-vs-jung-similarities-differences.htm. 

Forrer, Kurt. “View of ‘To Test or Not to Test, That Is the Question’ - Is There a Way of Verifying the Validity of the Interpretation of Our Dreams?” International Journal of Dream Research, Oct. 2014, journals.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/index.php/IJoDR/article/view/15033/pdf_80.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog #1 : Topics for Consideration

Image
I've had quite a bit of trouble trying to pick only one topic to focus on and as I kept researching more topics, I found even more fascinating topics to choose from. My first initial thought was to pick the Bermuda Triangle, but after researching more topics I realized that there are other topics I find more fascinating. While the Bermuda Triangle is well-known and interesting, I have read multiple articles explaining that scientists believe that there was no mystery to begin with. Many say that the reason for the high number of disappearances is due to bad weather conditions and the science behind ocean waves.    So after removing the Bermuda Triangle off my list of topics, I decided to look at topics that deal with space because I have always been interested in what is beyond our universe and anything that deals with space. I started to look at the theory of a multiverse. A multiverse is a collection of parallel universes or also known as alternate realities. I have always been i
Read more

Blog #3 : Research Question and 3 Scholarly Sources

Image
Some questions I thought of while looking through different articles and scholarly sources. Almost every person has experienced déjà vu, but not many people look into the truth behind it. Why does déjà vu happen and what is the true meaning behind it?  Is it our mind falsely creating memories and tricking us into thinking we have already been through this experience?  Why does déjà vu happen more to specific groups of people? Why does déjà vu include feelings of postdictive bias and not just predictive bias?  Can you stop yourself from experiencing déjà vu? If so, how can you stop yourself from experiencing  déjà vu? Scholarly Sources: Cleary AM, Claxton AB. Déjà Vu: An Illusion of Prediction. Psychological science . 2018;29(4):635-644.      doi:10.1177/0956797617743018 Cleary AM, Huebert AM, McNeely-White KL, Spahr KS. A postdictive bias associated with déjà vu. Psychonomic bulletin & review . 2019;26(4):1433-1439. doi:10.3758/s13423-019-01578-w Cleary AM, Ryals AJ, Nomi JS. Can d
Read more

Blog #2 : Scouting the Territory

Image
Out of the many topics I wrote about in my last blog post, I’ve decided to pick déjà vu. With déjà vu I feel like I can go in depth with the psychology behind it and also since déjà vu is such a well known topic that many people have experienced, it would be cool to be able to tell people about why this happens to us. Some key terms that can be associated with déjà vu are memory, false memories, and psychology. The term “déjà vu” is french for “already seen” so the term memory fits into this phenomenon by acting as if we have already been through a certain event, but possibly our memory was not good enough to realize this. False memories was an interesting term to me and definitely a term I want to focus more on because it takes a different approach by stating that we are creating these false memories and acting as if it is our memory. We sort of trick our minds into thinking we have been through a certain event already, but we’re not exactly sure how which leaves us with this confusin
Read more